Among dozens of brands out there, Kamado Joe and Big Green Egg are thousands of people’s favorite. It’s a choice between freshness and legend.
A lot of people are familiar with grills made by Big Green Eggs since their models were the first kind in the grilling world, but also they helped kamado grills become a choice for those who love outdoor cooking.
However, Kamado Joe has been able to make its way up to the top with its incredible, continued innovations tailored to all-inclusive accessory packages.
As such, both brands are compared continuously, which makes choosing a bit challenging and overwhelming. Thus, in this review, we’ll compare all necessary features and details about kamado grills of both brands to help you make the right choice.
Considering the things or factors to keep in mind, such as warranty, innovativeness, efficiency in cooking, and others that will steer you right. Without further ado, here’s a comparison of the outstanding features of both brands.
- 1 Kamado Joe vs. Big Green Egg – Features Comparison
- 2 Top 5 Best Kamado Joe and Big Green Egg Grills
- 2.1 1. Char-Griller E16620 Akorn Kamado Kooker Charcoal Barbecue Grill
- 2.2 2. Kamado Joe KJ23RHC Classic II Ceramic Charcoal Grill
- 2.3 3. Kamado Joe KJ13RH Portable Versatile Kamado Charcoal Grill
- 2.4 4. KamadoJoe BJ24NRHC Big Joe II Stand-Alone kamado Charcoal Grill
- 2.5 5. Big Green Egg Wooden Shelves EGG Mate
- 3 Final Verdict
Kamado Joe vs. Big Green Egg – Features Comparison
While you can’t go wrong with either Big Green Egg or Kamado Joe, they offer some perks over each other.
So, let’s dig in!
Stainless Steel Upgrades
For most kamado grill models out there, they are usually made of ceramic and come with the same base constructions. The difference is the specific features and upgrades, each brand offers.
Kamado Joe makes its models not only attractive but also compatible to use as an outdoor grill, with its upgraded Stand-Alone grills coming with several stainless steel features. Stainless steel cooking, stainless steel hinge, stainless steel handle, stainless steel bands, stainless steel upper vent, and stainless steel cooking grates.
While Big Green Joe does not offer a lot of upgrades with a lot of stainless steel, it still comes with extra stainless steel cooking grates.
Top Air Vent
When purchasing a new grill, one of the most important thing to look out for is the type of material the top air vent is made of.
Kamado Joe models come with an aluminum upper air vent, which makes it rust-resistant. Further, it’s construction is a bit different, as well. At the sides, there are small air flow regulators to help open the upper part of the air vent allowing more room for more air to flow in via the bigger opening.
As for Big Green Egg, cast iron is used instead. This means after a couple of months; you may be dealing with a rusting top air vent. That’s not the only downside. Their design has a flaw. When the lid opens the top air vent tends to change its position, which means you need to regulate again.
Fairly speaking, while cast iron tends to corrode easily, it’s not so difficult to handle since rusting does not happen on the inside except the outer parts. As such, if notice your top air vent of Big Green Egg starts to corrode, remove and brush it, and revert its beauty by painting again.
Ash Removal System
Needless to say, kamado grill runs on charcoal, which means you should expect an enormous amount of charcoal ash being produced, especially if you are going for a large model.
Now, let’s take a look at what both brand score on this feature.
Kamado Joe – in terms of managing ash debris, we think Kamado Joe scores higher than its competitor Big Green Egg. The manufacturer designs allow an easy-to-carry ash drawer to be placed behind the grill’s bottom air vent. This unique design makes cleaning a breeze. Just remove the drawer, throw away the charcoal ash, and replaced in its position. Plus, its ash removal system is quick and very easy.
Big Green Egg – while this brand has almost the same ash removal system like the Kamado Joe, cleaning up the ash has to be done manually using an ash rake. That’s not the hard part, each time you are cleaning you have to be careful else your cooked steak might get dirty.
To be fair, Big Green Egg comes with an easy cleaning system, too. But, we think its competitor Kamado Joe offers a better and cleaner system.
Even though both brands always add a built-in thermometer, usually, on the lid’s top side, they still some minor advantages over each other.
For instance, the Classic Joe 18 inches from Kamado Joe comes with a built-in thermometer which is almost two times the size of the one placed on the Large Big Green Egg grill. Don’t forget, the bigger the thermometer, the clearer and easier you can check the grilling temperature.
Grills from Kamado come with a dual rack system allowing users to customized the grates’ height based on whatever food they decide to cook on the product.
Additionally, the manufacturer includes a tool to make it easy to grab the already-hot rack. This helps to ensure you can move the hot grates without hurting yourself, wasting time or without facing any challenges.
Big Green Egg
Unlike Kamado Joe, they come with grates having standard height.
Therefore, if you wish to have the grate a bit lower – remove the ceramic plates. This process sometimes can be time-consuming and very frustrating, as well.
All in all, grills from any of the brands offer a decent and good cooking experience, with ample space for several steaks, ribs, burgers, and many others. Plus, there’s only a slight difference in their cooking performance.
This is one of factor; Big Green Egg fails to be impressive. The manufacturer sells their grills without including any additional accessories at all. In fact, they fail to include some ‘necessary’ accessories need for basic and remarkably grilling experience, such as shelves, stainless steel grate, cart – just to mention a few. This put Big Green Egg at a huge disadvantage. So, to enjoy your grilling experience, you have to purchase these ‘required’ accessories, which, in the long run, becomes too pricey comparing the number of attachments you have to buy.
But for Kamado Joe, they include a wealth of additional accessories to ensure every user gets fun and enjoyable cooking sessions. However, their some extra but not so necessary accessories you may decide to buy, as most of the essential accessories come with the grill.
Top 5 Best Kamado Joe and Big Green Egg Grills
Best Kamado Grills
1. Char-Griller E16620 Akorn Kamado Kooker Charcoal Barbecue Grill
When it comes to a product that last, Char-Griller E16620 Akorn Kamado Kooker Charcoal Barbecue Grill is built with 22 gauge steel. The interior is porcelain enameled steel, and an exterior finish is a powder plated steel, sturdy construction built to withstand the test of time.
The Char-Griller E16620 Akorn Kamado Kooker Charcoal Barbecue Grill is designed to retain heat; thanks to its triple-walled construction, which also help maintain temperatures from 200 to 700 degrees F.
Further, this model comes with an average of 314 sq. In. Of cast iron cooking space and an additional 133 sq. In. Removable warming rack. Also, the grill offers easy temperature controls. The adjustable dampers at the top and bottom help ensure steady inflow and outflow of air while smoking or cooking. Another incredible benefit of the kamado design is its fuel efficiency; allowing users to make use of less charcoal for smoking or cooking.
Large locking wheels
Folding side shelf
The lid may not stay on
2. Kamado Joe KJ23RHC Classic II Ceramic Charcoal Grill
For those looking to have a grill perfect for on-the-go grilling – camping, RV, tailgating, and many more, then you that considering Kamado Joe KJ23RHC Classic II Ceramic Charcoal Grill. This unit has a thick-walled, heat-resistant ceramic shell, which helps maintain temperatures from 225 – 750 degrees F by locking in moisture and smoke.
On top of that, the Kamado Joe KJ23RHC Classic II Ceramic Charcoal Grill has a total cooking surface of 406 sq. in with a primary cooking space of 230 sq. In. This average space should be enough to cook food for a family of 3 and a few friends. Further, this unit has a Versatile Divide & Conquer Flexible Cooking System that allows users to cook different foods, at the different temperatures in a different style.
What’s more? The Kamado Joe KJ23RHC Classic II Ceramic Charcoal Grill comes with a large built-in thermometer, which makes it easier to read.
Divide and Conquer Cooking System
Element conquering Kontrol Top Tower
Slide-Out Ash Drawer
Easy to read built-in thermometer
Some customers complained of defective products upon delivery
3. Kamado Joe KJ13RH Portable Versatile Kamado Charcoal Grill
This small grill is designed to be transportable, which makes it great for picnics, tailgates, camping, pool parties, and more. This innovative grill from Kamado Joe weighing only 68 pounds has an ample space boasting of 148.5 sq. In. Cooking surface. This space is enough to cook steaks, chicken, etc. for a family of 3 or less than.
Also, its construction features a thick-walled ceramic body that helps retain heat, flavor, and moisture. The product is powder coated cast iron to ensure durability and longevity. Besides, it includes a built-in thermometer that makes sure you are cooking at the right temperature. Last, but not the least, Kamado Joe KJ13RH Portable Versatile Kamado Charcoal Grill includes grill gripper and ash tool, unlike other brands out there.
Built to last
A wide temperature range
Setting up may be a bit difficult
4. KamadoJoe BJ24NRHC Big Joe II Stand-Alone kamado Charcoal Grill
For those who love to grill multiple dishes and still want to have fun while cooking with your guest, then Kamado Joe BJ24NRHC Big Joe II Stand-Alone kamado Charcoal Grill maybe what the doctor just ordered.
The interior of this 24 inches ceramic grill is well-insulated, which makes it easy to regulate the grilling temperature and turn the grill into a smoker. Furthermore, this unit works well with ordinary charcoal to add slightly lip-smacking flavors to your meat, chicken, etc.
Like other units from Kamado Joe, it has a Divide & Conquer cooking system and comes with a stainless steel cooking grates making it easier to use in a lot of positions. Plus, it comes with two smaller racks which are not up to the full rack size.
Speaking of smaller racks, they are perfect for cooking some particular foods not far from the heat and maintain the other foods temperature, so you don’t serve a cold dish. That’s not all: it comes with ceramic heat deflectors, which comes in handy when you don’t need the heat at the moment.
Rain-proof, no-rust, all-aluminum, control Tower top vent
Durable and portable
divide & conquer flexible cooking system
Easy to clean
This model seems to be on the pricey side
Best Big Green Egg Grill
5. Big Green Egg Wooden Shelves EGG Mate
The Big Green Egg Grill & Smoker is designed to improve users cooking experience on the BGE grill. This stylish and durable wood design is attached right to the extra large, large or medium Egg. The folding shelves give you more room to prep your produce without consuming a lot of space. This wooden shelves fold down for easy storing away and also makes it hassle-free to fit under the BGE grill cover.
More, this grill offers more working surface, with space for hanging utensils on for quick access and organization. Another impressive feature is easy to clean up with any mild household detergents. In fact, with proper cleaning, this model will look like new for a couple of more years.
Durable and stylish
Easy to clean
Different size options
Fold down shelves
Controlling the temperature may be a bit challenging
At the beginning of this comparison, we believed that Kamado Joe would be easily come out under, but actually, we gave Big Green Egg more advantage.
This brand produces grills that bear a resemblance to an egg and come in a wide range of sizes for those who love backyard grilling or want a cooking experience on the go.
On the other hand, the Kamado Joe produce more grills than its competitors Big Green Egg. Plus, their products come at affordable price, which we think is why kamado grill ranks higher on this review at the end.