14 Best Electric Fireplace Insert Reviews by Consumer Reports 2019

In recent times, electric fireplace inserts have become more popular, and it’s usage have become wider. This is due to several advantages that come with electric fireplace inserts.

They are easy to set up, cheaper than gas and wood fireplaces, and very easy to maintain. These products do not produce smoke like other types of fireplace.

Electric fireplace inserts are designed to produce life-like looking flames, with ember logs that look like real burning logs. Also, it is easier to control temperature on electric fireplace inserts than on gas and wood fireplaces.

All these features have endeared a lot of people to electric fireplace inserts. For this article, we have reviewed some of the best electric fireplace inserts on the market, to make it easier for you to choose among the various options available.

Top 14 Best Electric Fireplace Insert by Consumer Reviews 2019

1. Duraflame Electric DFI030ARU Infrared Quartz Set Heater

 

This electric fireplace insert comes with a very life-like ember bed and log set, all you need to do is to place it in the fireplace and watch the flames burn. You can enjoy the flame effect on this insert, whether or not you turn on the heat and you can easily control the log set from any position in the room using the advanced remote control functions.

It comes with a 5,200 BTU heater, the infrared quartz heat help to maintain humidity and the dancing flames make for a great addition to the decoration of your interior.

The advantages of infrared heat include even heating, healthier space, and maintenance of natural humidity in the air; so with this Duraflame Electric Fireplace insert, you don’t have to worry about the air in the room drying out.

However, you have to make sure that you do not place any flammable material near the fireplace to avoid fire outbreak. With this fireplace insert, you can evenly heat up to 1000 square feet of space, so even if your room is large, the heat will be evenly distributed.

2. Duraflame DFI020ARU-A004 Electric Fireplace Insert with Heater

 

Duraflame is well known for its electric stoves and fireplaces, and like their other products, this electric fireplace insert is very functional and environmentally friendly. It comes with a 4,600 BTU heater, and it will heat up to 400 square feet of space evenly.

It also comes with a very realistic ember bed and logs set with an interesting flame effect that you can use with or without you turning on the heat. The LED lights are long-lasting, you do not need any vent to use it, it is effortless to set up, and in general, the set consumes low energy.

Just like with any other electric fireplace insert, you should be careful not to place any flammable material close to the fireplace to avoid fire incidents. The realistic flame effect will truly delight you, and at the press of a button on the remote control, you can easily adjust both the heat and the flame.

If you are looking for a durable and functional electric fireplace insert to provide you with heat and add to the beauty of your room, you can’t go wrong with the Duraflame DFI020ARU-A004 Electric Fireplace Insert with Heater.+-

3. PuraFlame 30″ Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Remote Control

 

This is another elegant and energy-saving electric fireplace insert that comes with a multi-function remote control feature that will make it easier for you to control the set from anywhere in the room.

It provides a realistic flames effect that is made possible by the backlit LEDs, and you can switch between three different intensities. Also, the ember bed and logs are very life-like, giving that same feeling that a wood or gas fireplace will provide you with. The beautiful flame effect can be put on with or without turning the heat on, so when you don’t need the heat, you can still enjoy the beauty of the burning flame effect.

To prevent any fire incident, the set comes with an overheating protection feature, but you should still make sure that you do not put anything flammable or combustible near the fireplace. You can also trust the PuraFlame 30″ Western Electric Fireplace Insert to serve up to 400 square feet of space.

4. Dimplex DFI2309 Electric Fireplace Insert

 

The flame technology on this insert is patented, and it will be tough to come across an electric fireplace insert that works the same. It is straightforward to install; all you have to do is to put the insert in the fireplace opening, plug it into any standard outlet, and watch it come to life.

For easy, quiet and good even heat distribution, this insert has a fan-forced heater built in it. You also get to choose between full heat, half heat, or flames only option; whenever you do not need the heat, you can still bring your room to life with the beautiful flame effect.

Add to the decor of your room with this beautiful fireplace insert. The carefully-made logs are very lifelike and the embers glow just like the real thing. The LED lights that make the flames come alive are long-lasting, and they consume lower energy when you compare them with incandescent bulbs.

If you are looking for an electric fireplace insert that will fit right into your fireplace, the Dimplex DFI2309 Electric Fireplace Insert should be on your list.

5. Touchstone 80004 Sideline Electric Fireplace

 

This electric fireplace insert is one of those that provide up to three different flame colors. It features two heat settings and five different flame settings ranging from a soft amber glow to a strong glaze.

All these settings can be easily controlled from anywhere in the room by the remote control, and the dual mode feature allows you to turn on the flame effect even when you are not using the heat.

Also, you can choose to install this electric fireplace on your wall, or you can just put it in your fireplace. The faux logs and glass crystals give the fireplace a very authentic look, offering the same feeling a traditional fireplace would give while allowing you more control than the traditional ones.

It is true that you can install this fireplace anywhere. However, you should make sure that you don’t put it close to combustible materials.

6. Pleasure Hearth LH-24 Electric Log Insert with Heater

 

Add heat and beauty to your interior space with this Pleasure Hearth electric insert. Designed to heat up to 400 square inches of space, you can easily add this set to your fireplace to bring life to your room and at the same time provide heat for you and your family during cold periods.

The 4,600 BTU heater is fan-forced for even heating, and the insert can work without you turning on the heat. All different features can be controlled easily and from anywhere in the room with the multi-function remote control.

One of the things people look for in electric fireplace inserts is life-like flames and realistic ember bed and logs, all of which are included in this insert. Additionally, the insert is designed to fit most pre-constructed fireplaces, so you don’t have to worry about this unit not fitting into your fireplace.

7. Dimplex DFI2310 Electric Fireplace Deluxe 23-Inch Insert

 

Put your old fireplace to use with this deluxe fireplace insert. Designed to fit into the most pre-fabricated fireplace, this insert will bring life into your interior space, while providing even heat for you and your family.

It saves energy, and it is cleaner and healthier to use because it doesn’t produce any smoke. The various heat and flame settings can be controlled from anywhere in the room by using the remote control.

The flame technology is unique, and it is patented, so your interior space will have that unique look that you cannot find easily elsewhere. It is straightforward to set up, the heater is fan-forced to ensure even heat distribution, and it is powerful enough to heat up to 400 square feet of space.

If what you are looking for is a simple electric fireplace insert that will heat up and brighten up your space, this is a good one for you.

8. Comfort Glow Electric Log Set with Heater

 

 

This is another exciting electric place insert that provides even heat for your interior space without the mess and smoke that comes with traditional fireplaces. It produces a realistic yellow flame that will brighten up your room even if you don’t turn on the heat.

The LEDs that produce this lighting effect are energy efficient, and the glowing logs are very life-like.

The 5000 BTU heater is powerful enough to provide sufficient heat for common interior spaces, while a circulating lower that is installed with the heater ensures even heat distributions.

It doesn’t require any expertise to set up, and it is designed to fit into most pre-constructed fireplaces. Some people prefer inserts that have a sound feature; sadly, this insert doesn’t.

9. ClassicFlame 36EB220-GRT 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert

 

This ClassicFlame insert gives your interior space a very modern look while providing the warmth that traditional fireplaces offer.

Zone heating is an incredible feature that is included in this insert, and it makes for better energy conservation by shutting off the heat being directed to unoccupied spaces.With this insert, you have greater control over heat distribution, and you will save more energy by using it.

The LED flame effect, the ember bed, and the log set are all very life-like, and the heat and flame effect can be controlled easily by remote control. It is also possible to enjoy the beauty of the flame effect without turning on the heat, but when the heat is needed, it can serve up to 800 square feet of space.

10. Flameline Dannis In-Wall Recessed Electric Fireplace Heater

 

Providing ultra-realistic flames housed in contemporary design; this is one of the most elegant electric fireplaces you can get around. It is suitable for any room, and the burning log effect and crystal effect are all so life-like.

The realistic flame has three different colors, and you can turn it on with or without the heat turned on. The in-wall feature is what makes it perfect for any room in your house and makes it a sophisticated addition to your decor.

The 5,100 BTU heater can easily provide heat for up to 450 square feet of space and protection from overheating is guaranteed by the overheat protection switch.

For ease of use, it comes with a multi-function remote control to control the heat and flame features. However, do not place it near combustible materials for safety purpose.

11. Classic Flame 23II042FGL 23″ 3D Infrared Quartz Electric Fireplace Insert

 

Add this beautiful insert to your pre-constructed fireplace and enjoy the warmth it provides, while immersing in the beauty of the realistic dancing flames that will make the decor of your interior perfectly.

The 3D flame effect is patented, and it provides very realistic flames that you can turn on even when you do not turn the heat on. This flame effect offers five different burning settings from a gentle flame to a roaring fire.

Furthermore, you can also select the brightness with which you want the insert to operate, depending on your mood and the lighting of the room. Instant warming is made possible by the infrared technology, and this technology also ensures that the insert does not dry out the air in the room, unlike traditional fireplaces.

12. Comfort Glow ELCG251 Electric Log Insert

 

Restore the beauty of your fireplace with this Comfort Glow insert. It produces a realistic dancing flame that is projected onto the firebox walls.

The 4,600 BTU heater has a circulating blower that will ensure even heat distribution. You do not have to necessarily turn the heat on before you can enjoy the beauty of the dancing flames; with or without the heat turned on, you can turn on the flame.

To suit different moods and ambiance, the insert comes with five different brightness settings, all of which can be controlled by the remote control. The glowing ember bed is also very realistic, and the side mounted controls make the insert look more realistic. With all these exciting features, this electric fireplace remains very affordable.

13. Dimplex DLGM29 Opti-Myst Open Hearth Fireplace Insert with Faux Log Bed

 

Indeed, this is one of the unique looking fireplace inserts you will ever see. It uses a very peculiar ultrasonic technology to create a flame and smoke effect.

However, it is totally safe for the environment, the smoking effect notwithstanding. This realistic effect is achieved when the mist rises through the logs, and the light reflects against the water molecules; the result of this is the realistic appearance of burning logs and smoke.

As it produces no flame nor smoke, it is one of the safest options for you. It does require water refilling, but the water tank is big enough to use for 14 hours, and it is easy to refill. Unlike most electric inserts, this one is safe to touch as it is fitted with a glass front that remains cool to touch.

14. MagikFlame Electric Fireplace

 

This is one of the very few electric fireplace inserts that produce a crackling fire sound. It is a very suitable piece for your living room, and it makes your interior space more inviting.

It heats your interior space, and it doesn’t pollute or mess up your room because it doesn’t produce smoke, and it doesn’t require constant addition of fuel. The premium metal piece is white, and the delicate wood logs are handcrafted to perfection.

The flame simulation is authentic, with the burning log and embers. Another exciting thing about this insert is that it is very easy to set up, so without any prior expertise, you can easily set it up. You will do well not to put any combustible material near the insert to avoid fire incidents.